"which consisted of" vs "which consisted in"

Question

"which consisted of" vs "which consisted in"

Both 'which consisted in' and 'which consisted of' are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'Which consisted in' is used to introduce a clause that explains the nature or essence of something, while 'which consisted of' is used to list the components or elements that make up something.

Last Updated: March 29, 2024

This phrase is used to introduce a list of the components or elements that form something.

Examples:

The salad, which consisted of lettuce, tomatoes, and cucumbers, was delicious.
The team, which consisted of experienced professionals, achieved great results.
The book, which consisted of ten chapters, covered a wide range of topics.

Alternatives:

which was composed of
which was made up of
which included
which comprised
which was formed by

This phrase is used to introduce a clause that describes the essential nature or quality of something.

Examples:

The success of the project, which consisted in careful planning and execution, was evident to all.
His argument, which consisted in logical reasoning, was convincing.
The beauty of the painting, which consisted in its vibrant colors, captivated the viewers.

Alternatives:

which was characterized by
which was defined by
which was marked by
which was exemplified by
which was represented by

Answer 1

which consisted of

This phrase is correct and is used to list the components or elements that make up something.

Answer 2

which consisted in

This phrase is correct and is used to introduce a clause that explains the nature or essence of something.

"which consisted of" vs "which consisted in"

which consisted of

which consisted in

Related Comparisons