"you are my student" vs "you became my student"

Question

"you are my student" vs "you became my student"

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'You became my student' implies a past action where someone started being your student at a specific point in time. 'You are my student' indicates the current status of someone being your student. The choice between the two depends on whether you are referring to the initiation of the student-teacher relationship or the ongoing status of being a student.

Last Updated: March 08, 2024

This phrase is used to describe the ongoing relationship where someone is currently your student. It indicates the present status of being a student.

Examples:

You are my student for this semester.
She is my student in the advanced class.

Alternatives:

You study with me.
You are learning from me.

This phrase is used to refer to the past action of someone becoming your student. It implies a specific moment when the student-teacher relationship began.

Examples:

I remember the day you became my student.
She became my student last year.

Alternatives:

You started studying with me.
You began learning from me.

Answer 1

you are my student

This phrase is correct and commonly used to indicate the current status of someone being your student.

Answer 2

you became my student

This phrase is correct and commonly used to indicate that someone started being your student at a specific point in time.

"you are my student" vs "you became my student"

you are my student

you became my student

Related Comparisons