"have been broken" vs "have become broken"

Question

"have been broken" vs "have become broken"

Both "have become broken" and "have been broken" are correct, but they are used in different contexts. "Have become broken" implies a change in state or condition, indicating that something was not broken before but is now. On the other hand, "have been broken" simply states that something has been broken without emphasizing the change in state.

Last Updated: March 31, 2024

This phrase is used to simply state that something has been broken without emphasizing the process of becoming broken.

Examples:

The window has been broken by the storm.
The rules have been broken by some players.
The vase has been broken into pieces.
The trust between them has been broken.
The silence has been broken by a loud noise.

Alternatives:

have suffered breakage
have been shattered
have been damaged
have been fractured
have been cracked

This phrase is used to describe something that was not broken before but is now. It emphasizes the process of becoming broken.

Examples:

The vase has become broken after falling off the shelf.
Her heart has become broken after the breakup.
The relationship has become broken due to lack of communication.
The once beautiful painting has become broken over time.
His spirit has become broken after facing multiple failures.

Alternatives:

has turned broken
has grown broken
has deteriorated into a broken state
has transformed into a broken condition
has shifted into a broken state

Answer 1

have been broken

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English to indicate that something has been broken.

Answer 2

have become broken

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English to indicate a change in state or condition.

"have been broken" vs "have become broken"

have been broken

have become broken

Related Comparisons