Which one is correct?
"you seem to have given" or "you seemed to give"?

Question

Which one is correct?
"you seem to have given" or "you seemed to give"?

TextRanch: The best way to perfect your writing.

Discover why 1,062,726 users count on TextRanch to get their English corrected!

One of our experts will correct your English.

100% Human-Powered Editing!

This phrase is used to express an observation or opinion about something that has happened recently or is still happening.

Examples:

You seem to have given a lot of thought to this project.
You seem to have given up on your dream of becoming an artist.

Alternatives:

It seems like you have given
You appear to have given

This phrase is used to describe an action that was perceived or observed in the past but is no longer the case.

Examples:

You seemed to give your best effort in the competition.
You seemed to give up on your goal last year.

Alternatives:

It seemed like you gave
You appeared to give

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'You seem to have given' is used when referring to a current situation or recent past action. 'You seemed to give' is used when talking about a past action that is no longer relevant or has been completed.

Last Updated: March 31, 2024