Who is this girl with you. vs Who is she with you.

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'Who is this girl with you?' is used when the speaker is referring to a girl who is physically present, while 'Who is she with you?' is used when the speaker is asking about a girl who is not present but is associated with the person being addressed.

Last updated: April 01, 2024 • 1279 views

This phrase is correct and commonly used when referring to a girl who is physically present.

"Who is this girl with you."

This phrase is used when the speaker is asking about the identity of a girl who is currently with the person being addressed.

Examples:

Who is this girl with you? She looks familiar.
Who is this girl with you? Is she your sister?

Show examples from the web [+]

Who is this girl to you?
Father, who is this girl?
"Marin, who is this girl?" chiede Shaina.
Father, who is this girl?
Seriously, who is this girl?
I mean, who is this girl?
I mean, who is this girl that you're marrying?
Who is this girl and why is she talking to me?
Who is this girl Andrew's going out with?
OK. So who is this girl?
Who is this girl that looks exactly like her?
So, who is this girl in prison?
Who is this girl you took to the theatre tonight?
"Who is this girl, Don FeIipe?"
Who is this girl you're going with?
Who is this girl to you?
Provide this girl with great pain and suffering.
"Mother taught me to smother" is this girl's motto.
There is this girl at my health club.
The one we're worried about is this girl.

This phrase is correct and commonly used when asking about a girl who is not physically present but is associated with the person being addressed.

"Who is she with you."

This phrase is used when the speaker is inquiring about the identity of a girl who is not currently present but is connected to the person being spoken to.

Examples:

Who is she with you? I've heard a lot about her.
Who is she with you? Is she your girlfriend?

Show examples from the web [+]

Someone at the hospital who is really digging you.
Guy named Michael Donacosta, who is...
Who is now in federal prison.
Who is responsible for this tragedy.
That participant who is mistaken, - leaves.
Who is mistaken - leaves game.
Who is poorer - cooked noodles from cornmeal.
Who is sensitive, bring mosquito repellent.
My constituents regularly ask who is running Spain.
The Guess Who isn't American.
Who is way more important than Al Capone.
Suppose there giuseppe who is a carpenter.
Then get me somebody who is.
Look who is standing at the church door.
I have been contacted by a constituent who is resident in Bulgaria and lives with his wife who is not an EU citizen.
We could see on the cameras overhead who is a terrorist and who is a civilian.
For only the Church controls who is called and who is not.
Communications picked up conversations in the Manrique district between Jairo, who is one of Escobar's sicarios, and his mother, who is ill.
I would like to welcome Mr Solomon Passy, Bulgarian Foreign Affairs Minister, who is visiting Parliament today and who is in the official gallery.
This way, consumers will be able to know who is worthy of their business support and who is not.

Our Customers Love Us!

We have an average rating of 4.79 stars based on 283125 votes, and

4.9 Excellent - Reviews 2.137

"7 years without any disappointment. Always 100% satisfied. You guys are the best in the world at what you do. Thank you so much :)"

Zubair
from Bangladesh

"I wasn't aware of this service, it's fascinating and more reliable than standard IA tools available on the internet"

Arturo
from Mexico

"In a world of text messages and online communication, this is great to have as a live tool. Thank you."

Selena
from USA

"Wow, it's just so excellent. I never would have believed I could have a sure and excellent English companion. Thanks, TextRanch."

Ifiok
from Nigeria

"This is my first time using TextRanch, and I like how the editors take time to correct my text. To everyone who has never used TextRanch before, I highly recommend trying it."

Wilson
from France

"It is an amazing source of feedback because, as a non-native speaker, I really need to have a reliable helper correct my text."

Susan
from Germany

Who is this girl with you. vs Who is she with you.

"Who is this girl with you."

"Who is she with you."

Related Comparisons