TextRanch

The best way to perfect your writing.

Discover why 1,062,726 users count on TextRanch to get their English corrected!

1. Input your text below.
2. Get it corrected in a few minutes by our editors.
3. Improve your English!

One of our experts will correct your English.

Our experts

when he arrived she already left vs when he arrived she has already left

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'When he arrived she already left' is used to describe two past actions in sequence, where the action of leaving happened before the action of arriving. 'When he arrived she has already left' is used to emphasize that the action of leaving happened before a specific point in the past (his arrival).

Last updated: March 24, 2024

when he arrived she already left

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English to describe two past actions in sequence.

This phrase is used to indicate that the action of leaving happened before the action of arriving, in the past.

Examples:

  • When he arrived, she already left the party.
  • By the time he got home, she already left for work.
  • Only when he arrived did Grandma become suspicious.
  • Your son was dead when he arrived here.
  • When he arrived, I had just sung that number.
  • When he arrived, looks like our sniper drilled him between the shoulders.
  • But it's nothing compared to his fits of anger when he arrived.
  • This was with Legadus, saw when he arrived.
  • Your raft was already on fire when he arrived.
  • Grace had no intention of going with her father when he arrived.
  • That's why Cardassians were chasing Tahna Los when he arrived.
  • He didn't want to talk to Sisko when he arrived.
  • When he arrived at her shack, she was already dead.
  • When he arrived, I made coffee.
  • Custodian found the body when he arrived for work this morning.
  • It would explain why your recent lapses in concentration started when he arrived.
  • He had that when he arrived.
  • I had just finished pouring myself a glass of wine when he arrived.
  • Dan practically ran the other way when he arrived.
  • He found his wife's body when he arrived home later that night.
  • But Mr. Goldstein requested that in his office when he arrived.
  • Nick was gone when he arrived on the scene, and I told him it's on me.

Alternatives:

  • By the time he arrived, she had already left.
  • When he arrived, she had already departed.

when he arrived she has already left

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English to emphasize that the action of leaving happened before a specific point in the past (his arrival).

This phrase is used to highlight that the action of leaving occurred before a specific point in the past, in this case, his arrival.

Examples:

  • When he arrived, she has already left for the airport.
  • By the time he got there, she has already left the building.
  • Only when he arrived did Grandma become suspicious.
  • I had just finished pouring myself a glass of wine when he arrived.
  • Dan practically ran the other way when he arrived.
  • He found his wife's body when he arrived home later that night.
  • Custodian found the body when he arrived for work this morning.
  • He had that when he arrived.
  • It would explain why your recent lapses in concentration started when he arrived.
  • When he arrived, looks like our sniper drilled him between the shoulders.
  • When he arrived, I had just sung that number.
  • This was with Legadus, saw when he arrived.
  • But it's nothing compared to his fits of anger when he arrived.
  • But Mr. Goldstein requested that in his office when he arrived.
  • Grace had no intention of going with her father when he arrived.
  • Your raft was already on fire when he arrived.
  • That's why Cardassians were chasing Tahna Los when he arrived.
  • He didn't want to talk to Sisko when he arrived.
  • When he arrived at her shack, she was already dead.
  • Your son was dead when he arrived here.
  • When he arrived, I made coffee.
  • When he arrived, it was clear we'd all served our purpose.

Alternatives:

  • By the time he arrived, she had already left.
  • When he arrived, she had already departed.

Related Comparisons

when he arrived she left vs when he arrived she alrady left when he arrived she already left vs when he arrived she had already left when he arrived she left vs when he arrived she has already left when he arrived she has already left vs when he arrived she have already left when he arrived she has already left vs when he arrived she had already left

What Our Customers Are Saying

Our customers love us! We have an average rating of 4.79 stars based on 283,125 votes.
Also check out our 2,100+ reviews on TrustPilot (4.9TextRanch on TrustPilot).

Why choose TextRanch?

Lowest prices
Up to 50% lower than other online editing sites.

Fastest Times
Our team of editors is working for you 24/7.

Qualified Editors
Native English experts for UK or US English.

Top Customer Service
We are here to help. Satisfaction guaranteed!