"she never talked" vs "she has never talked"

Question

"she never talked" vs "she has never talked"

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. "She never talked" is used to describe a past action that never occurred, while "she has never talked" is used to emphasize that up to the present moment, she has not talked. The choice between the two depends on the timeframe you want to refer to.

Last Updated: March 23, 2024

This phrase is used to indicate that at no point in the past did she talk. It refers to a specific time in the past when talking did not happen.

Examples:

She never talked to him during the entire meeting.
He realized she never talked about her childhood.
They found out she never talked to her neighbors.
She never talked about her feelings with anyone.
She never talked about her past.

Alternatives:

She didn't talk.
She never spoke.
She remained silent.
She refrained from talking.
She kept quiet.

This phrase is used to indicate that from the past up to the present moment, she has not talked. It emphasizes the continuity of the action of not talking.

Examples:

She has never talked about her personal life.
He realized she has never talked to him before.
She has never talked to her coworkers about her hobbies.
She has never talked to her family about her dreams.
She has never talked to anyone about her fears.

Alternatives:

She hasn't talked.
She never spoke.
She has refrained from talking.
She has kept quiet.
She has remained silent.

Answer 1

she never talked

This phrase is correct and commonly used to describe a past action that never occurred.

Answer 2

she has never talked

This phrase is correct and is used to emphasize that up to the present moment, she has not talked.

"she never talked" vs "she has never talked"

she never talked

she has never talked

Related Comparisons