she asked if I had made the payment vs she asked if I have made the payment

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. The first phrase 'she asked if I had made the payment' is in the past perfect tense, indicating an action that was completed before a certain point in the past. The second phrase 'she asked if I have made the payment' is in the present perfect tense, indicating an action that was completed recently or has relevance to the present.

Last updated: March 24, 2024 • 2176 views

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English. It is in the past perfect tense, indicating an action completed before a certain point in the past.

"she asked if I had made the payment "

This phrase is used when referring to an action that was completed before a certain point in the past. It is often used in reported speech or storytelling.

Examples:

She asked if I had made the payment before the deadline.
He wondered if I had finished the project on time.

Show examples from the web [+]

She asked if I had protection on her, and I said yes.
She asked if I had a position on your campaign.
She asked if I had an opinion about the results of the medical investigation of Dr. Farland.
She asked if I could get us some wine.
Then she asked if I could convince Carter to forgive her.
Then she asked if I wanted to open up a bank account.
I gave the profile to one woman, she asked if i was the unsub.
Rachel had to go to chicago for the weekend, So she asked if I could look after ella.
She asked if I could cover and I said that I could.
She asked if I could go into the kitchen and get us some wine.
She asked if I'd come over.
So when she asked if I'd help, well, my answer just had to be...
We fooled around, and in the shower she asked if I could arrest Paisley instead of Mama Liu.
And when this case is over, and we get back she asked if I would help her do it.
Before she passed, she asked if I'd take over her job at the foundation.
She asked if I am OK, and I thanked her.
I was just heading out to Isbister's do and she asked if I could take her along.
She asked if I liked it, and... I was honest.
She asked if I'd be part of this weekend's Nebula 9 Fan Experience.
She asked if I could relieve her for a few ticks.

Alternatives:

She asked if I made the payment.
She asked if I had paid.
She asked if I had completed the payment.
She asked if I had settled the payment.

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English. It is in the present perfect tense, indicating an action that was completed recently or has relevance to the present.

"she asked if I have made the payment "

This phrase is used when referring to an action that was completed recently or has relevance to the present. It is often used in situations where the timing of the action is important.

Examples:

She asked if I have made the payment this month.
He inquired if I have sent the email yet.

Show examples from the web [+]

She asked if I could get us some wine.
Then she asked if I could convince Carter to forgive her.
She asked if I had protection on her, and I said yes.
She asked if I had a position on your campaign.
Then she asked if I wanted to open up a bank account.
I gave the profile to one woman, she asked if i was the unsub.
Rachel had to go to chicago for the weekend, So she asked if I could look after ella.
She asked if I could cover and I said that I could.
She asked if I could go into the kitchen and get us some wine.
She asked if I'd come over.
So when she asked if I'd help, well, my answer just had to be...
We fooled around, and in the shower she asked if I could arrest Paisley instead of Mama Liu.
She asked if I had an opinion about the results of the medical investigation of Dr. Farland.
And when this case is over, and we get back she asked if I would help her do it.
Before she passed, she asked if I'd take over her job at the foundation.
She asked if I am OK, and I thanked her.
I was just heading out to Isbister's do and she asked if I could take her along.
She asked if I liked it, and... I was honest.
She asked if I'd be part of this weekend's Nebula 9 Fan Experience.
She asked if I could relieve her for a few ticks.

Alternatives:

She asked if I made the payment.
She asked if I have paid.
She asked if I have completed the payment.
She asked if I have settled the payment.

Our Customers Love Us!

We have an average rating of 4.79 stars based on 283125 votes, and

4.9 Excellent - Reviews 2.137

"7 years without any disappointment. Always 100% satisfied. You guys are the best in the world at what you do. Thank you so much :)"

Zubair
from Bangladesh

"I wasn't aware of this service, it's fascinating and more reliable than standard IA tools available on the internet"

Arturo
from Mexico

"In a world of text messages and online communication, this is great to have as a live tool. Thank you."

Selena
from USA

"Wow, it's just so excellent. I never would have believed I could have a sure and excellent English companion. Thanks, TextRanch."

Ifiok
from Nigeria

"This is my first time using TextRanch, and I like how the editors take time to correct my text. To everyone who has never used TextRanch before, I highly recommend trying it."

Wilson
from France

"It is an amazing source of feedback because, as a non-native speaker, I really need to have a reliable helper correct my text."

Susan
from Germany

she asked if I had made the payment vs she asked if I have made the payment

"she asked if I had made the payment "

"she asked if I have made the payment "

Related Comparisons