scientific substantiation vs scientific justification

Both 'scientific substantiation' and 'scientific justification' are correct phrases, but they are used in slightly different contexts. 'Scientific substantiation' is commonly used in the context of providing evidence or proof to support a scientific claim or statement. On the other hand, 'scientific justification' is often used to explain or defend the reasons behind a scientific decision or action.

Last updated: April 06, 2024 • 277 views

This phrase is correct and commonly used in scientific contexts to refer to providing evidence or proof to support a scientific claim or statement.

"scientific substantiation"

The term 'scientific substantiation' is used when there is a need to provide solid evidence or proof to support a scientific claim, theory, or statement.

Examples:

The study lacked scientific substantiation for its conclusions.
The scientific substantiation for the theory was based on extensive experimental data.

Show examples from the web [+]

This scientific substantiation should be proportional to the nature of the benefits offered by the product.
The scientific substantiation of nutrition and health claims should be proportionate to the claimed beneficial effects.
Furthermore EFSA conducts public consultations on draft guidance documents for the scientific substantiation of health claims.
More importantly, the Commission is confident that EFSA's assessments for the scientific substantiation of health claims are consistent with the requirements set out in the regulation.
Therefore, it is appropriate, when using psychological and behavioural claims, to require scientific substantiation.
The scientific substantiation shall be available at the time the feed is placed on the market.
In that opinion, the Authority also noted that no human studies from which conclusions could be drawn for the scientific substantiation of the claim were provided by the applicant.
The additional information submitted by the applicant, in the context of Question No EFSA-Q-2013-00659, did not provide evidence that could be used for the scientific substantiation of the claim.
The Authority added that the new published meta-analysis does not provide additional information for the scientific substantiation of the extension of the conditions of use to plant sterol esters in powder.
Where there are doubts regarding the scientific substantiation of a health claim the Authority may, at the request of the Commission, draw up an opinion.
(b) the person responsible for the labelling provides on request of the competent authority a scientific substantiation of the truthfulness of the claim, either via publicly available scientific evidence or through documented company research.
In the event of a negative opinion by the Authority about the scientific substantiation of the claim, the claim shall have to be authorised in accordance with the procedures laid down by Article 17.
Pursuant to that regulation, any claim that a food (or one of its constituents) has an impact on health needs to be authorised at European level once its scientific substantiation had been assessed by the European Food Safety Authority.
Where a Member State has serious grounds for considering that a claim does not comply with this Regulation, or that the scientific substantiation provided for in
Where the competent authority has doubts regarding the scientific substantiation of the claim concerned, it may submit the issue to the Commission.
Thereafter, consumers shall have the right to receive from the competent authority a summary of the scientific substantiation or, where there are justified grounds for suspecting that a misleading claim has been made, to ask the competent authority to have such substantiation provided by the manufacturer.
Registration of the claim shall be granted by the Commission within 5 months from the date of receipt of the request for registration unless the Authority objects by way of a negative opinion on the scientific substantiation of the claim.
Guidelines will be established by the Authority regarding the type of scientific substantiation that an operator must have to justify use of a nutrition or health claim, with the level of substantiation required being proportional to the claim that is being made.
Where there are such serious concerns with regard to the scientific substantiation of a health claim that a favourable opinion by the Authority cannot be expected, the Commission may prohibit the continued use of the health claim.
Where a Member State has serious grounds for considering that a claim does not comply with this Regulation, or that the scientific substantiation provided for in Article 6 is insufficient, that Member State may temporarily suspend the use of that claim within its territory.

Alternatives:

scientific evidence
scientific proof
scientific validation
scientific confirmation
scientific support

This phrase is correct and commonly used to explain or defend the reasons behind a scientific decision or action.

"scientific justification"

The term 'scientific justification' is used when there is a need to explain or defend the reasons behind a scientific decision, action, or conclusion.

Examples:

The scientist provided a detailed scientific justification for her research methodology.
There was a strong scientific justification for the new environmental policy.

Show examples from the web [+]

Parliament should be consulted on any increases and provided with the scientific justification.
However, in such cases a scientific justification must be provided.
The competent authority may grant an exemption from the first subparagraph on the basis of scientific justification.
In certain circumstances and with proper scientific justification, solids may also be tested neat by direct application onto the corneal surface using the open chamber method (see paragraph 29).
The scientific justification for mandatory labelling of these allergenic ingredients has been provided by the EFSA Scientific Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA).
And, as it says in Amendment No 7, and I quote, "the scientific justification for laying down new conditions is based on the situations obtaining in the northern European countries".
A scientific justification is to be provided, however;
With appropriate scientific justification, carcinogenicity studies may be carried out in one rodent species, preferably the rat.
In these cases, a scientific justification shall be provided, accompanied by the details of the anaesthetic or analgesic regimen.
Such acute effects are essentially instantaneous and there is no scientific justification to modify the exposure limit values for exposure of short duration.
The CoR notes that the margin of tolerance is an arbitrary figure for which there is no scientific justification.
There are several reasons to believe that there may be scientific justification for the use of zappers.
The Parties shall ensure that SPS measures are developed and applied on the basis of the principles of proportionality, transparency, non-discrimination and scientific justification.
The increase in fishing foreseen in the agreement must also be dependent upon unequivocal and independent scientific justification, which must be made available to the Parliament.
Therefore, in order to allow the use of this marketing tool for profit, we must make sure that it has the correct scientific justification and that it is substantiated scientifically.
Please note that attaching a document is not feasible in an xml bulk file; therefore the only way to include such an SCL or M-factor and to attach the requested scientific justification is to submit a C&L notification using IUCLID or the online tool.
On the contrary, I accept the argument of the Pelagic RAC that such harvest rules represent a 'blunt' instrument which could lead to dramatic and unwarranted reductions in TAC and would thus undermine the viability of the fishery and destabilise the industry without adequate scientific justification.
By way of derogation from paragraph 1, the competent authority, on the basis of scientific justification, may allow re-use of an animal
There was no scientific justification for the decision taken and no account was taken of the position of the countries concerned.
On the other hand, there must be strong scientific justification and a system of limit points must be put in place.

Alternatives:

scientific rationale
scientific explanation
scientific reasoning
scientific basis
scientific grounds

How TextRanch works

Fast and reliable proofreading, editing, and language advice tailored to your needs.

1. Choose Your Service

Quick Text Editing

Emails and short texts
Proofreading & editing
Ready in 5-10 minutes

SUBMIT YOUR TEXT NOW

Document Editing

Documents of any type (*.docx)
Advanced & Premium editing
Ready in as little as 4 hours

UPLOAD YOUR DOCUMENT

Ask an Editor

Personalized answers to your language questions
Expert guidance on grammar, style, and usage
Ready in 24 hours

ASK YOUR QUESTION

Upload your document or paste your text directly into our platform. Your text is reviewed and refined by our expert editors (real people, not machines) who understand the nuances of English. Expect corrections, improvements, and insightful suggestions that enhance the clarity, tone, and professionalism of your writing.

3. Receive Your Polished Text

In just a few minutes (or hours for longer documents), you'll receive your corrected text. Review the changes, make any final adjustments, and confidently share your polished English with the world.
You can count on a personalized, friendly service every time you use TextRanch. We're committed to helping you make a great impression with every word you write.

We proofread and edit these types of texts and documents:

Short texts Business Emails Personal Emails Social media posts Resume and Curriculum Vitae Business documents Sales proposal Research and academic papers Thesis Dissertation Essays Articles Blog posts and much more....

Our Customers Love Us!

We have an average rating of 4.79 stars based on 283125 votes, and

4.9 Excellent - Reviews 2.137

"7 years without any disappointment. Always 100% satisfied. You guys are the best in the world at what you do. Thank you so much :)"

Zubair
from Bangladesh

"I wasn't aware of this service, it's fascinating and more reliable than standard IA tools available on the internet"

Arturo
from Mexico

"In a world of text messages and online communication, this is great to have as a live tool. Thank you."

Selena
from USA

"Wow, it's just so excellent. I never would have believed I could have a sure and excellent English companion. Thanks, TextRanch."

Ifiok
from Nigeria

"This is my first time using TextRanch, and I like how the editors take time to correct my text. To everyone who has never used TextRanch before, I highly recommend trying it."

Wilson
from France

"It is an amazing source of feedback because, as a non-native speaker, I really need to have a reliable helper correct my text."

Susan
from Germany

scientific substantiation vs scientific justification