"One of those was broken" vs "One of my guitars was broken"

Question

"One of those was broken" vs "One of my guitars was broken"

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. "One of my guitars was broken" is used when referring to a specific item from a group that belongs to the speaker. On the other hand, "one of those was broken" is used when referring to a specific item from a group that is not owned by the speaker.

Last Updated: March 15, 2024

This phrase is used when referring to a specific item from a group that is not owned by the speaker that was broken.

Examples:

One of those was broken, so we had to replace it.
One of those was broken, and we had to fix it before using it.
One of those was broken, and we couldn't use it anymore.
One of those was broken, and we had to throw it away.
One of those was broken, and it was a shame.

Alternatives:

One of them was broken
One of those items was broken
One of those things was broken
One of those objects was broken
One of those possessions was broken

This phrase is used when talking about a specific guitar that belongs to the speaker that was broken.

Examples:

One of my guitars was broken, so I had to take it to the repair shop.
One of my guitars was broken, but luckily I have others to play.
One of my guitars was broken, and I need to buy a new one.
One of my guitars was broken, and I can't play it until it's fixed.
One of my guitars was broken, and I'm upset about it.

Alternatives:

One of my guitars is broken
One of my guitars has been broken
One of my guitars got broken
One of my guitars got damaged
One of my guitars got ruined

Answer 1

One of those was broken

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English.

Answer 2

One of my guitars was broken

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English.

"One of those was broken" vs "One of my guitars was broken"

One of those was broken

One of my guitars was broken

Related Comparisons