it would be no discussion if you had said this since the beginning vs it would be no discussion if you have said this since the beginning

The correct phrase is: 'it would be no discussion if you had said this since the beginning.' The use of 'had said' in the past perfect tense is appropriate in this context to indicate that the action of saying something happened before another past event. 'Have said' in the present perfect tense would not be suitable here.

Last updated: March 24, 2024 • 466 views

This phrase is correct. It uses the past perfect tense 'had said' to indicate an action that occurred before another past event.

"it would be no discussion if you had said this since the beginning"

This phrase is used to express that if someone had said something from the beginning, there would be no discussion or disagreement.

Show examples from the web [+]

There's no discussion if you've already decided what's right.
If you crash in it, you'll probably get killed... "But the dangerous one's two seconds a lap quicker." There would be no discussion about which one they'd drive.
We should have a discussion if you're up to it.
There would be no discussion in the media about why we have an economic system that allows a pilot to be paid less than a manager at Taco Bell.
Then when I discovered that there would be no discussions on that revision regarding Article 25 of the IIA, I was, to say the least, somewhat disappointed.
Mrs Oomen-Ruijten, you have shaken my good faith in you, since I had already told you that there would be no discussion on this matter.
I can foresee a very long and very difficult discussion if this is going to take place.
Then let us have some discussions if we want some changes, but we do not change the pension scheme by a resolution put down at the last minute.
There are numerous questions concerning details of the individual market regulations which we can certainly include in the discussion if so desired.
Perhaps the money launderers themselves are also following these proceedings with a great deal of interest since it would be a happy outcome of our discussions if their life were to be made more difficult.
In my opinion, it will not help us to make progress in future discussions if we launch an attack on private broadcasting in this report at European level.
How can it be end of discussion if there's never been a discussion?
2. Any member of the Council may oppose discussion if the texts of any proposed amendments are not drawn up in such of the languages referred to in paragraph 1 as he or she may specify.
For the EDD group, William ABITBOL (EDD, F) drew attention to reported comments of the Polish Prime Minister that there would be no point in continuing discussions if agreement could not be reached within six months.
For the EDD group, William ABITBOL (EDD, F) drew attention to reported comments of the Polish Prime Minister that there would be no point in continuing discussions if agreement could not be reached within six months.
In a spirit of compromise and openness, we agree to reopen this discussion if the Commission for its part agrees to reconsider its proposal and to give a hearing to the European Parliament's proposals.
Secondly, the developing countries must also be brought into this discussion if it concerns them, for they do not wish to have standards imposed on them over their heads either, standards they have played no part in formulating.
Please read the first 50 pages for discussion tomorrow, If you would.
How can it be end of discussion if there's never been a discussion?
The Commission may also decide to discontinue settlement discussions if the parties to the proceedings coordinate to distort or destroy any evidence relevant to the establishment of the infringement or any part thereof or to the calculation of the applicable fine.

This phrase is incorrect. The use of 'have said' in the present perfect tense is not suitable in this context, as it does not convey the correct sequence of events.

"it would be no discussion if you have said this since the beginning"

Show examples from the web [+]

There's no discussion if you've already decided what's right.
If you crash in it, you'll probably get killed... "But the dangerous one's two seconds a lap quicker." There would be no discussion about which one they'd drive.
We should have a discussion if you're up to it.
There would be no discussion in the media about why we have an economic system that allows a pilot to be paid less than a manager at Taco Bell.
Then when I discovered that there would be no discussions on that revision regarding Article 25 of the IIA, I was, to say the least, somewhat disappointed.
Mrs Oomen-Ruijten, you have shaken my good faith in you, since I had already told you that there would be no discussion on this matter.
I can foresee a very long and very difficult discussion if this is going to take place.
Then let us have some discussions if we want some changes, but we do not change the pension scheme by a resolution put down at the last minute.
There are numerous questions concerning details of the individual market regulations which we can certainly include in the discussion if so desired.
Perhaps the money launderers themselves are also following these proceedings with a great deal of interest since it would be a happy outcome of our discussions if their life were to be made more difficult.
In my opinion, it will not help us to make progress in future discussions if we launch an attack on private broadcasting in this report at European level.
How can it be end of discussion if there's never been a discussion?
2. Any member of the Council may oppose discussion if the texts of any proposed amendments are not drawn up in such of the languages referred to in paragraph 1 as he or she may specify.
For the EDD group, William ABITBOL (EDD, F) drew attention to reported comments of the Polish Prime Minister that there would be no point in continuing discussions if agreement could not be reached within six months.
For the EDD group, William ABITBOL (EDD, F) drew attention to reported comments of the Polish Prime Minister that there would be no point in continuing discussions if agreement could not be reached within six months.
In a spirit of compromise and openness, we agree to reopen this discussion if the Commission for its part agrees to reconsider its proposal and to give a hearing to the European Parliament's proposals.
Secondly, the developing countries must also be brought into this discussion if it concerns them, for they do not wish to have standards imposed on them over their heads either, standards they have played no part in formulating.
Please read the first 50 pages for discussion tomorrow, If you would.
How can it be end of discussion if there's never been a discussion?
The Commission may also decide to discontinue settlement discussions if the parties to the proceedings coordinate to distort or destroy any evidence relevant to the establishment of the infringement or any part thereof or to the calculation of the applicable fine.

How TextRanch works

Fast and reliable proofreading, editing, and language advice tailored to your needs.

1. Choose Your Service

Quick Text Editing

Emails and short texts
Proofreading & editing
Ready in 5-10 minutes

SUBMIT YOUR TEXT NOW

Document Editing

Documents of any type (*.docx)
Advanced & Premium editing
Ready in as little as 4 hours

UPLOAD YOUR DOCUMENT

Ask an Editor

Personalized answers to your language questions
Expert guidance on grammar, style, and usage
Ready in 24 hours

ASK YOUR QUESTION

Upload your document or paste your text directly into our platform. Your text is reviewed and refined by our expert editors (real people, not machines) who understand the nuances of English. Expect corrections, improvements, and insightful suggestions that enhance the clarity, tone, and professionalism of your writing.

3. Receive Your Polished Text

In just a few minutes (or hours for longer documents), you'll receive your corrected text. Review the changes, make any final adjustments, and confidently share your polished English with the world.
You can count on a personalized, friendly service every time you use TextRanch. We're committed to helping you make a great impression with every word you write.

We proofread and edit these types of texts and documents:

Short texts Business Emails Personal Emails Social media posts Resume and Curriculum Vitae Business documents Sales proposal Research and academic papers Thesis Dissertation Essays Articles Blog posts and much more....

Our Customers Love Us!

We have an average rating of 4.79 stars based on 283125 votes, and

4.9 Excellent - Reviews 2.137

"7 years without any disappointment. Always 100% satisfied. You guys are the best in the world at what you do. Thank you so much :)"

Zubair
from Bangladesh

"I wasn't aware of this service, it's fascinating and more reliable than standard IA tools available on the internet"

Arturo
from Mexico

"In a world of text messages and online communication, this is great to have as a live tool. Thank you."

Selena
from USA

"Wow, it's just so excellent. I never would have believed I could have a sure and excellent English companion. Thanks, TextRanch."

Ifiok
from Nigeria

"This is my first time using TextRanch, and I like how the editors take time to correct my text. To everyone who has never used TextRanch before, I highly recommend trying it."

Wilson
from France

"It is an amazing source of feedback because, as a non-native speaker, I really need to have a reliable helper correct my text."

Susan
from Germany

it would be no discussion if you had said this since the beginning vs it would be no discussion if you have said this since the beginning