if you had told me before vs if you would have told me before

Question

A complete search of the internet has found these results:

if you had told me before is the most popular phrase on the web.

Some examples from the web:

Mar 2, 2015 ... If You Had Told Me Before Today That We Would Have A Legit Swaggy P vs Robert Flores Feud I Wouldn't Have Believed You But Here We ...
Type III: unreal conditions in the past "If you had told me before, I would have helped you." Be careful: NEVER USE "WOULD" IN AN IF-CLAUSE! To find out ...
Jan 28, 2015 ... If you had told me before I had kids that the chance to watch “Parenthood” on the DVR would be the lap of luxury, well….Read more…
Feb 2, 2015 ... If you had told me before the game that Brady would finish with 50 passes, I would have they'd lose by 3 touchdowns. Slinging it into that ...

Some examples from the web:

Jan 12, 2015 ... If you would have told me before then though, I really would have laughed and probably hollered “Get thee behind me Satan!” I would have ...
Mar 1, 2015 ... If you would have told me before I went to see Kingsman that I'll enjoy a movie made by Matthew Vaughn, I would have never believed it.
Jan 5, 2015 ... “If you would have told me before the year (Vontaze) Burfict was going to play two games and the corners were going to be dinged up some of ...
If you would have told me before season 1 that this was the lineup for this show I would have been legitimately interested. I would have thought, wow, this is like ...

Answer 1

More popular!

if you had told me before

800 results on the web

Answer 2

329 results on the web