"I thought you were my" vs "I thought you'd be my"

Question

"I thought you were my" vs "I thought you'd be my"

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'I thought you'd be my' is used when referring to a future expectation that did not come true, while 'I thought you were my' is used when talking about a past belief that turned out to be incorrect.

Last Updated: March 15, 2024

This phrase is used to convey a sense of realization or disappointment when you discover that someone you believed to be a certain way is not what you thought.

Examples:

I thought you were my friend, but you betrayed me.
I thought you were my soulmate, but we grew apart.
I thought you were my ally, but you sided with the enemy.
I thought you were my confidant, but you shared my secrets.
I thought you were my hero, but you let me down.

Alternatives:

I thought you were going to be my
I thought you were going to become my
I thought you were going to end up being my
I thought you were going to turn out to be my
I thought you were going to evolve into my

This phrase is used to convey a sense of disappointment or surprise when someone did not meet the expectations you had for them.

Examples:

I thought you'd be my best friend, but you let me down.
I thought you'd be my mentor, but you never showed up to help me.
I thought you'd be my partner in this project, but you disappeared.
I thought you'd be my support system, but you weren't there when I needed you.
I thought you'd be my inspiration, but you turned out to be just like everyone else.

Alternatives:

I thought you'd become my
I thought you'd end up being my
I thought you'd turn out to be my
I thought you'd evolve into my
I thought you'd transform into my

Answer 1

I thought you were my

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English when expressing a past belief that was proven wrong.

Answer 2

I thought you'd be my

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English when expressing a past expectation that did not materialize.

"I thought you were my" vs "I thought you'd be my"

I thought you were my

I thought you'd be my

Related Comparisons