Which one is correct?
"I spoke to the man whose number you had given me" or "I spoke to the man whose number you gave me"?

TextRanch: The best way to perfect your writing.

Discover why 1,062,726 users count on TextRanch to get their English corrected!

One of our experts will correct your English.

Our experts

100% Human-Powered Editing!

I spoke to the man whose number you had given me

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English.

This phrase is used to indicate that the speaker spoke to a man before receiving his number.

Alternatives:

  • I spoke to the man whose number you had provided me with.

I spoke to the man whose number you gave me

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English.

This phrase is used to indicate that the speaker spoke to a man after receiving his number.

Alternatives:

  • I spoke to the man whose number you provided me with.
Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. The first phrase 'I spoke to the man whose number you gave me' is used when referring to a past action that happened after the number was given. The second phrase 'I spoke to the man whose number you had given me' is used when referring to a past action that happened before the number was given.

Last Updated: March 28, 2024

Related Comparisons

Why choose TextRanch?

Lowest prices
Up to 50% lower than other online editing sites.

Fastest Times
Our team of editors is working for you 24/7.

Qualified Editors
Native English experts for UK or US English.

Top Customer Service
We are here to help. Satisfaction guaranteed!