Which one is correct?
"Have you ever heard a band" or "Have your ever heard a concert"?

Question

Which one is correct?
"Have you ever heard a band" or "Have your ever heard a concert"?

TextRanch: The best way to perfect your writing.

Discover why 1,062,726 users count on TextRanch to get their English corrected!

One of our experts will correct your English.

100% Human-Powered Editing!

This phrase is used to inquire about someone's experience listening to a musical group or ensemble.

Alternatives:

Have you ever listened to a band?
Have you ever heard a musical group?
Have you ever heard a music ensemble?
Have you ever heard a music band?
Have you ever heard a music group?

This phrase can be used to ask if someone has ever attended a concert and listened to the music being performed.

Alternatives:

Have you ever been to a concert?
Have you ever listened to a concert?
Have you ever attended a concert?
Have you ever experienced a concert?
Have you ever enjoyed a concert?

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'Have you ever heard a concert?' is not a common question because concerts are events where music is performed, not something you 'hear.' On the other hand, 'Have you ever heard a band?' is a more common question as bands are groups of musicians that produce music. Therefore, the second phrase is more appropriate when asking about someone's experience with music.

Last Updated: March 15, 2024

Answer 1

Have you ever heard a band

This phrase is grammatically correct and commonly used in English. Bands are groups of musicians that produce music, so it makes sense to ask if someone has heard a band.

Learn More [+]

Answer 2

Have your ever heard a concert

This phrase is grammatically correct but not commonly used in English. Concerts are events where music is performed, not something you 'hear.'

Learn More [+]

Which one is correct? "Have you ever heard a band" or "Have your ever heard a concert"?

Have you ever heard a band

Have your ever heard a concert

Related Comparisons

Which one is correct?
"Have you ever heard a band" or "Have your ever heard a concert"?