"did you have taken" vs "have you taken"

Question

"did you have taken" vs "have you taken"

The phrase 'have you taken?' is correct, while 'did you have taken' is incorrect. 'Have you taken?' is the correct form to ask about a completed action in the present perfect tense. It is commonly used in English.

Last Updated: March 22, 2024

This phrase should not be used. The correct form is 'have you taken?' to ask about a completed action in the present perfect tense.

Use 'have you taken?' to ask someone if they have completed a specific action. It is a common way to inquire about past actions in English.

Examples:

Have you taken your medicine?
Have you taken the dog for a walk?
Have you taken the test yet?
Have you taken out the trash?
Have you taken a break today?

Answer 1

did you have taken

This phrase is incorrect. 'Did you have taken' is not a valid construction in English.

Answer 2

have you taken

This phrase is correct and commonly used in English to ask about a completed action in the present perfect tense.

"did you have taken" vs "have you taken"

did you have taken

have you taken

Related Comparisons