Born in Kolkata erstwhile Calcutta located in the Indian state of West Bengal vs Kolkata erstwhile Calcutta located in the Indian state of West Bengal

Both phrases are correct, but the first one is more complete and grammatically accurate. The addition of 'born in' at the beginning of the sentence provides clarity and context to the statement. The second phrase is also correct but lacks the subject, making it less clear.

Last updated: April 01, 2024 • 349 views

This phrase is correct and provides a clear subject ('born in') at the beginning of the sentence.

"Born in Kolkata erstwhile Calcutta located in the Indian state of West Bengal"

This phrase is used to indicate the birthplace of someone, specifying that they were born in Kolkata, formerly known as Calcutta, located in the Indian state of West Bengal.

Show examples from the web [+]

In the Indian State of Maharashtra, sugarcane and lucerne are often grown on the same farm, together with dairy cows.
Eighteen months after the outbreak of communal violence in the Indian state of Orissa, many people are still living in sub-standard, temporary accommodation.
Subject: Attacks on Christians in the Indian state of Punjab
In the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh alone 247.800 children work in cottonseed production and around 450.000 in whole India, most of them for Indian-owned companies.
With this in mind the Jesuit Fathers who run St Francis Xavier High School in Nettiah in the Indian state of Bihar have included Sanskrit lessons as part of school activities.
Madagascar is a beautiful country located in the Indian Ocean, off the southeastern coast of Africa.
It is located in the Indian Ocean, about 25 miles from the Tanzanian coast, and 6º south of the equator.
It is located in the Indian Ocean, off the south-eastern coast of Africa, from which is separated by the Mozambique Channel.
The privatisation of power in the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh resulted in electricity charges rising by 60-80% for agricultural users and 30-50% for domestic users.
Anantnag is a district in the Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir. It is one of eight districts which make up the Kashmir Valley.
Seychelles - an independent republic located on an archipelago consisting of 90 islands located in the Indian Ocean, approximately 2000 km from the East Coast of Africa.
The Council welcomes initiatives such as the recent introduction by the Government of India, in the Indian Parliament, of the Communal Violence Suppression Bill, which gives special powers to the central government to deal with communal violence in Indian states.
appalled by the recent sectarian violence which took place in the Indian state of Gujarat and has claimed more than 900 lives, according to available figures,
French is also the official language of Mayotte and Réunion, two overseas territories of France located in the Indian Ocean, as well as an administrative and educational language in Mauritius, along with English.
We are located in the center of the Business Hub Karol Bagh and thus, are the prime choice of tourists and business delegations coming from all parts of the world for their stay in the Indian capital.
the appropriate declarations of conformity (Associates) are emitted by ClassNK in confront of yards R.L Kalthia Ship Breaking Pvt. Ltd. and Priya Blu Industries Pvt. Ltd., both situated to Alang/Bhavnagar, in the Indian state of Gujarat.
The Indian State actually practices positive discrimination in favour of the lower castes.
Reunion is a small island situated in the Indian Ocean.
Piracy in the Indian Ocean is increasingly detrimental to tuna fishing.
Another amendment in my original report concerned transhipment in the Indian Ocean.

This phrase is correct but lacks a subject, making it less clear.

"Kolkata erstwhile Calcutta located in the Indian state of West Bengal"

This phrase can be used to provide information about the city of Kolkata, formerly known as Calcutta, located in the Indian state of West Bengal.

Show examples from the web [+]

In the Indian State of Maharashtra, sugarcane and lucerne are often grown on the same farm, together with dairy cows.
Eighteen months after the outbreak of communal violence in the Indian state of Orissa, many people are still living in sub-standard, temporary accommodation.
Subject: Attacks on Christians in the Indian state of Punjab
In the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh alone 247.800 children work in cottonseed production and around 450.000 in whole India, most of them for Indian-owned companies.
With this in mind the Jesuit Fathers who run St Francis Xavier High School in Nettiah in the Indian state of Bihar have included Sanskrit lessons as part of school activities.
The privatisation of power in the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh resulted in electricity charges rising by 60-80% for agricultural users and 30-50% for domestic users.
Anantnag is a district in the Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir. It is one of eight districts which make up the Kashmir Valley.
appalled by the recent sectarian violence which took place in the Indian state of Gujarat and has claimed more than 900 lives, according to available figures,
the appropriate declarations of conformity (Associates) are emitted by ClassNK in confront of yards R.L Kalthia Ship Breaking Pvt. Ltd. and Priya Blu Industries Pvt. Ltd., both situated to Alang/Bhavnagar, in the Indian state of Gujarat.
Madagascar is a beautiful country located in the Indian Ocean, off the southeastern coast of Africa.
It is located in the Indian Ocean, about 25 miles from the Tanzanian coast, and 6º south of the equator.
It is located in the Indian Ocean, off the south-eastern coast of Africa, from which is separated by the Mozambique Channel.
He served in Kotagiri, Katpadi, Negombo (Sri Lanka) and Tirupattur, and in 1975 came to the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh.
Seychelles - an independent republic located on an archipelago consisting of 90 islands located in the Indian Ocean, approximately 2000 km from the East Coast of Africa.
The Indian state of Punjab is an example of a liberal society comprising various religious communities which has stood up against terrorism and is committed to democracy.
Chennai is the capital of the indian state of Tamil Nadu. It's the seventh largest city in India to incorporate a subway system.
The reply I received from a State Minister of the Indian State of Andarpradesh to my question how many people lived in that province, will always stay with me.
The Emir of the Indian State of Kudjrad had bodyguards that came from the Horn of Africa.
The Council welcomes initiatives such as the recent introduction by the Government of India, in the Indian Parliament, of the Communal Violence Suppression Bill, which gives special powers to the central government to deal with communal violence in Indian states.
French is also the official language of Mayotte and Réunion, two overseas territories of France located in the Indian Ocean, as well as an administrative and educational language in Mauritius, along with English.

How TextRanch works

Fast and reliable proofreading, editing, and language advice tailored to your needs.

1. Choose Your Service

Quick Text Editing

Emails and short texts
Proofreading & editing
Ready in 5-10 minutes

SUBMIT YOUR TEXT NOW

Document Editing

Documents of any type (*.docx)
Advanced & Premium editing
Ready in as little as 4 hours

UPLOAD YOUR DOCUMENT

Humanize AI Content

AI-generated texts or documents (*.docx)
Check for errors and appropriateness
Rephrase to improve flow and style

SUBMIT YOUR AI CONTENT

Upload your document or paste your text directly into our platform. Your text is reviewed and refined by our expert editors (real people, not machines) who understand the nuances of English. Expect corrections, improvements, and insightful suggestions that enhance the clarity, tone, and professionalism of your writing.

3. Receive Your Polished Text

In just a few minutes (or hours for longer documents), you'll receive your corrected text. Review the changes, make any final adjustments, and confidently share your polished English with the world.
You can count on a personalized, friendly service every time you use TextRanch. We're committed to helping you make a great impression with every word you write.

We proofread and edit these types of texts and documents:

Short texts Business Emails Personal Emails Social media posts Resume and Curriculum Vitae Business documents Sales proposal Research and academic papers Thesis Dissertation Essays Articles Blog posts and much more....

Our Customers Love Us!

We have an average rating of 4.79 stars based on 283125 votes, and

4.9 Excellent - Reviews 2.137

"7 years without any disappointment. Always 100% satisfied. You guys are the best in the world at what you do. Thank you so much :)"

Zubair
from Bangladesh

"I wasn't aware of this service, it's fascinating and more reliable than standard IA tools available on the internet"

Arturo
from Mexico

"In a world of text messages and online communication, this is great to have as a live tool. Thank you."

Selena
from USA

"Wow, it's just so excellent. I never would have believed I could have a sure and excellent English companion. Thanks, TextRanch."

Ifiok
from Nigeria

"This is my first time using TextRanch, and I like how the editors take time to correct my text. To everyone who has never used TextRanch before, I highly recommend trying it."

Wilson
from France

"It is an amazing source of feedback because, as a non-native speaker, I really need to have a reliable helper correct my text."

Susan
from Germany

Born in Kolkata erstwhile Calcutta located in the Indian state of West Bengal vs Kolkata erstwhile Calcutta located in the Indian state of West Bengal