"a raise when you have proved you can do the job" vs "a raise when you proved you can do the job"

Question

"a raise when you have proved you can do the job" vs "a raise when you proved you can do the job"

Both phrases are correct, but they differ in terms of verb tense. The first phrase uses the simple past tense 'proved,' while the second phrase uses the present perfect tense 'have proved.' The choice between them depends on the context and the desired emphasis on the timing of the action.

Last Updated: March 27, 2024

This phrase uses the present perfect tense 'have proved' to show a link between the past action of proving one's ability and the present moment of receiving the raise.

Alternatives:

a raise when you proved you can do the job
a raise when you prove you can do the job
a raise after proving you can do the job
a raise upon proving you can do the job
a raise once you prove you can do the job

This phrase uses the simple past tense 'proved' to indicate a completed action of proving one's ability to do the job in the past.

Alternatives:

a raise when you have proved you can do the job
a raise when you prove you can do the job
a raise after proving you can do the job
a raise upon proving you can do the job
a raise once you prove you can do the job

Answer 1

a raise when you have proved you can do the job

This phrase is also correct and emphasizes the present perfect tense 'have proved,' indicating a connection between the past action of proving and the present moment of receiving the raise.

Answer 2

a raise when you proved you can do the job

This phrase is correct and conveys the idea of receiving a raise after proving one's ability to do the job.

"a raise when you have proved you can do the job" vs "a raise when you proved you can do the job"

a raise when you have proved you can do the job

a raise when you proved you can do the job

Related Comparisons