"have you studied until now?" vs "did you study until now?"

Question

"have you studied until now?" vs "did you study until now?"

Both phrases are correct, but they are used in different contexts. 'Have you studied until now?' is used to ask about a continuous action that started in the past and is still relevant in the present. 'Did you study until now?' is used to ask about a specific action that happened in the past up to the present moment.

Last Updated: April 06, 2024

This phrase is used to inquire if someone has been studying continuously from a point in the past up to the present moment.

Examples:

Have you studied until now or did you take a break?
Have you studied until now, or do you need more time?
Have you studied until now, or are you planning to continue?
Have you studied until now, or are you going to review more?
Have you studied until now, or are you ready for the test?

Alternatives:

Have you been studying up to this point?
Have you been studying until now?
Have you continued studying up to now?
Have you kept studying until now?
Have you been working on your studies until now?

This phrase is used to inquire if someone completed a study session or task from a point in the past up to the present moment.

Examples:

Did you study until now, or did you stop earlier?
Did you study until now, or did you take a break?
Did you study until now, or are you planning to continue?
Did you study until now, or are you ready for the test?
Did you study until now, or do you need more time?

Alternatives:

Have you studied up to this point?
Have you completed your study session until now?
Have you finished studying until now?
Have you stopped studying up to now?
Have you ended your study session until now?

Answer 1

have you studied until now?

This phrase is correct and commonly used to ask about a continuous action that started in the past and is still relevant in the present.

Answer 2

did you study until now?

This phrase is correct and commonly used to ask about a specific action that happened in the past up to the present moment.